top of page

Book a Free Coaching Session with a College Admissions Expert Today.

Test Optional Colleges: Should You Submit Your Scores?

2d
9 min read

Student compares an SAT score with transcript

Test optional colleges let you apply without an SAT or ACT score and still be considered fully. For most students the real question is whether to submit a score at each school. The answer depends on whether your score strengthens the story your transcript already tells. Policies are also moving: some of the most selective schools are bringing testing requirements back, so a plan built in ninth grade needs checking again in junior year. At Top College Coach, we help families build that plan school by school, with the lead counselor working directly with your student.



TL;DR

 

  • Test optional means the college considers your application without a score. It does not mean scores are ignored when you send them.

  • FairTest’s 2026–27 list shows most U.S. colleges as test-optional, but a few high-profile schools are returning to requirements.

  • Submit a score when it supports your transcript and sits comfortably in a school’s typical range. Withhold it when your grades, rigor and activities tell a stronger story.

  • Check each school’s policy page every fall, because rules, exceptions and deadlines differ by college, program and applicant type.

 

Table of Contents

 

 

What test optional actually means

 

A test optional college does not require an ACT or SAT score. FairTest defines it as a policy of considering applicants without requiring a score. Test-free, also called test blind, is different: those schools will not consider scores at all. The University of California and California State University systems are the best-known examples.

 

ACT’s own guidance adds a third category, test flexible. These schools accept alternatives such as AP or IB results in place of the SAT or ACT. ACT also notes that policies are specific to each college. Some schools require scores for certain programs or GPAs, or ask for them after you enroll.

 

So the label on a list is only the starting point. The policy page of each school on your list is the real rulebook.


What test optional actually means

How many colleges are test optional, and what is changing


How many colleges are test optional, and what is changing

FairTest’s 2026–27 list covers 2,111 U.S. colleges. It records 1,810 (85.7%) as test-optional, 81 as test-free, 161 requiring scores and 59 with no recorded policy. Those figures come from one year’s list and shift as schools update their rules, so treat them as the picture for 2026–27 rather than a permanent count.

 

The more important story for families of highly selective applicants is the direction of travel.

 

  • Princeton says it remains test-optional for fall 2027 entry and that applicants without scores will not be at a disadvantage. It will require SAT or ACT scores from the 2027–28 cycle, for fall 2028 enrollment, with active-duty military applicants exempt.

  • Notre Dame announced on September 9, 2026 that it will require ACT or SAT scores beginning with the 2027–28 cycle. Fall 2027 applicants remain test-optional. Notre Dame says its review found scores correlate strongly with classroom performance after enrollment.

  • University of Alabama in Huntsville is test-optional for entry through fall 2027 but requires scores from spring 2028 forward.

 

The pattern is useful to know. If your student is in ninth or tenth grade, the policies in place when they apply may not be the ones listed today. Preparing for the SAT or ACT early keeps every door open, whatever a school decides later.

 

Does applying without a score hurt you?

 

At a school that is genuinely test-optional, no. USC’s admissions office states that applicants will not be at a disadvantage for withholding scores, and that the high school transcript matters more than test performance. Princeton says the same for its current test-optional cycle.

 

What changes is how much else the reader has to go on. Grinnell explains that a high score can offset a lower GPA, because without a score the school has less information about academic performance. That is the key idea: a missing score is not a penalty, but it does remove one piece of evidence. Everything else in your application has to carry more weight.

 

How colleges read an application without scores

 

Miami University describes a holistic review of core curriculum, grades and trends, course rigor, essays, activities, talent, achievements and mitigating factors. USC notes that scores are most meaningful alongside transcript preparation, not in a vacuum.

 

In practice, this means a test-optional application succeeds on four things:

 

  1. Rigor. Strong courses for your school, taken with an upward trend in grades.

  2. A clear story. Activities that show a real interest pursued in depth, not a long list of clubs.

  3. Essays with a voice. Writing that shows who you are beyond a transcript.

  4. Context. Teacher recommendations and a school profile that explain your achievements.

 

Students who apply without scores should treat these four as non-negotiable. For more on what readers look for, see what top colleges look for in applications.

 

How to decide: submit or withhold

 

There is no universal rule, and admissions offices say so themselves. Barnard states it has no preference whether students submit and frames the decision as the student’s own. Washington and Lee suggests asking whether your results reflect your current academic ability and comparing them with its Class Profile. USC’s advice is to submit if you are proud of the score.

 

Here is a practical way to turn that advice into a decision for each school.

 

Step 1: Find the school’s middle range

 

Look up the middle 50% of submitted scores in the school’s Class Profile or Common Data Set. A score near or above the middle of that range helps you. A score well below it rarely adds anything.

 

Step 2: Compare it with the rest of your file

 

If your grades are strong and rigorous, a good score confirms what the transcript says. If your grades are uneven, a strong score offers evidence that the transcript does not. If both are modest for that school, no choice will carry the application, and the list itself needs another look.

 

Step 3: Account for the school’s submission rate

 

USC reports that only 50% of the previous year’s admits submitted scores. At schools where roughly half of admits send scores, withholding is common and normal. ACT notes that historically most students applying to test-optional schools still submit. Both facts can be true at once, so look at the school in front of you.

 

Step 4: Check superscoring and scholarship rules

 

Emory superscores both the SAT and ACT, combining your best sections across attempts. Washington and Lee does as well. If a school superscores, a second sitting can lift the number that gets read. Some schools also use scores for merit aid even when admission is test-optional, which is worth checking before you decide to withhold.

 

Step 5: Decide, then confirm before the deadline

 

Barnard lets students change their test-optional status in writing before the application deadline, with Early Decision scores due November 15 and Regular Decision February 28. Grinnell also requires the submit-or-withhold choice by its deadline. Put the decision for each school in a spreadsheet, with the date.

 

To see how we structure that decision with families, read our guides on applying test optional and test optional versus test blind.

 

Exceptions that catch families off guard

 

The phrase “test optional” hides fine print. These are the cases we see written into school policies:

 

  • Official score reports after admission. Bucknell lets all applicants choose test-optional status, but enrolling students who tested must submit official scores before their first year. Those scores are used to assess its pilot program, not the admission decision.

  • Self-reported scores. Washington and Lee says students who self-report must submit official reports after reserving a place, and discrepancies can lead to withdrawal of admission.

  • Extra steps instead of scores. Hampden-Sydney asks test-optional applicants to confirm the choice, write an essay and interview. International students needing to show English proficiency and homeschooled students may still need scores.

  • GPA expectations. UAH suggests a 3.5 high school GPA for test-optional candidates and makes offers conditional on official scores when scores are reported.

  • Program-specific requirements. Competitive majors, honors programs and scholarships can ask for more than the general policy does. Some arts programs add an audition or portfolio. Music applicants can see how a piano scholarship audition preparation plan is built around a performance rather than a number.

 

The habit that protects you is simple: read the full policy page for the school, then the page for your intended program.

 

A sample timeline for a test-optional strategy

 

Here is how the pieces fit for a student starting the process in ninth through twelfth grade.

 

Grade

What to do

9–10

Build a strong, rigorous transcript. Explore one or two interests in depth. Take the PSAT when your school offers it to see where you stand.

Spring of 10th to fall of 11th

Take two official practice tests and see which format suits you.

Winter and spring of 11th

Sit for the real exam if practice scores are competitive. Build a first draft of your college list.

Summer before 12th

Recheck each school’s policy page. Draft essays. Decide which schools get scores.

Fall of 12th

Confirm policies once more, finalize submit or withhold choices, and submit before deadlines.

If you are weighing a prep course, our look at ACT prep options for the enhanced ACT and a guide to PSAT scores can help you plan. For a wider view, see the role of standardized testing in admissions.

 

What this means for highly selective applications

 

At the most selective schools, nearly every admitted student has top grades and rigor. Test optional policies do not make those schools easier to get into. They make the application more about the whole file. When a school is moving back to requiring scores, as Princeton and Notre Dame are, a student who has already prepared has more options.

 

Our view is that a strong score is a tool to use selectively, not a hurdle to fear. A student who tests well should have the option of sending that score. A student whose strengths lie elsewhere should be confident applying without one at schools where that is truly welcome.

 

Where Top College Coach fits

 

Choosing school by school whether to submit takes judgment about each college’s policy, your student’s file and the timeline. At Top College Coach, each student works directly with the lead admissions counselor, not a junior staffer. Our packages cover Early High School Planning, Junior Year Preparation, The College List and The Application & Beyond, so the testing decision is made alongside course choices, essays and school selection rather than on its own. Applications can also be reviewed by former admissions officers, and students are mentored by current Ivy League students.


Top College Coach

If you would like help building a testing plan for your student, learn more about our personalized college admissions counseling or see the programs on our home page.

 

Our perspective

 

Families often come to us asking a yes or no question: should we submit? We think the better question is what the whole application says about this student, and what a score would add to that picture.   The best test-optional strategies begin long before senior year. A student who has taken rigorous courses, pursued a real interest and found an authentic voice in their essays can approach each school with confidence. The testing decision then becomes one piece of a larger puzzle, not a source of anxiety.   That is why we work with students directly, with smaller caseloads and personal attention. Each school on a list has its own policy, its own deadlines and its own way of reading an application, and your student deserves a plan that reflects that. Our goal is to help each student present their strongest and most authentic story, and to help parents feel steady about the process.   Randy Pryor

 

FAQ

 

Are test optional colleges easier to get into?

 

Not necessarily. Test optional only changes whether a score is required, not how competitive the applicant pool is. Selective schools still look for rigorous courses, strong grades, compelling essays and meaningful activities. Many applicants to those schools still send strong scores.

 

Can I still send scores to a test optional college?

 

Yes. Submitted scores are reviewed as part of the application, as Emory describes for its 2026–27 cycle. Send them when they support the rest of your file, and check each school’s deadline for making or changing that choice.

 

Which top colleges are bringing back test requirements?

 

Princeton will require scores starting with the 2027–28 cycle, and Notre Dame will do the same for fall 2028 applicants. Other schools have also revised their rules, so check the admissions page of every college on your list each fall rather than relying on an older list.

 

What if my score is below a school’s middle range?

 

In most cases, withhold it at a school where test-optional status is genuine, and let your transcript, essays and activities carry the application. Confirm first that the school has no program-specific or scholarship requirement that calls for scores. A counselor can review your list and help you decide school by school.

 

Sources

 

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page